Nintendo Faces Backlash Over Pokemon Pokopia Use of Switch 2's Game-Key Card

Nintendo Faces Backlash Over Pokemon Pokopia Use of Switch 2's Game-Key Card

Gamers are upset that they might not fully own the next Pokemon game.

Headshot of Oscar Gonzalez
Headshot of Oscar Gonzalez

Oscar Gonzalez Contributing writer

Oscar Gonzalez is a Texas native who covered video games, conspiracy theories, misinformation and cryptocurrency.

Expertise Video Games | Misinformation | Conspiracy Theories | Cryptocurrency | NFTs | Movies | TV | Economy | Stocks

When Nintendo revealed the Switch 2, it showcased the console's Game-Key Cards feature, which enables the storage of a small amount of data on the cartridge, with the remainder of the game being downloaded directly to the system. Expectations were that this would only be used by third-party developers for the new console, and that Nintendo would keep the entire game on the cartridges for those titles it publishes. 

That appears not to be the case with the newest Pokemon game. 

Pokemon Pokopia, a game that mixes the monster-catching game with a social game similar to Animal Crossing, will hit the Switch 2 on March 5, according to the Nintendo Store page for the game. For reasons not made clear by Nintendo, the game will use the Game-Key Card feature. To explain how it works, the company released a short video that has since garnered thousands of dislikes.

Why are people upset with Nintendo over the Game-Key Card feature? 

The reason for the dislikes stems from Nintendo not putting the entire game of Pokemon Pokopia on physical storage, requiring players to download the rest. A growing number of gamers are concerned about the lack of ownership of the games they have purchased. 

Publishers can delist games -- meaning they can remove the game from storefronts -- at any time. This can be due to a licensing issue, as seen with 2019's John Wick Hex. Since the film franchise has grown substantially since the game's release, the cost to license a game carrying that name has increased. Delisting a game is common with much older titles, but even a popular title that's just a generation old could be removed. PUBG for the PS4 and Xbox One was released in 2018, but the publisher announced in August that it would no longer support those versions, rendering them unplayable. 

Last year, a consumer movement began called Stop Killing Games, with the goal of challenging the legal rights of game companies to essentially destroy the games purchased by consumers. It has made strides in both the UK and EU, with hopes that the respective legislative bodies will pass consumer protection laws to prevent companies from disabling games that have already been purchased. 

How does the Game-Key Card feature work? 

When someone buys a game using this feature, the cartridge they receive will not contain the entire game. Instead, it will contain specific data that will require the Switch 2 to download the game. Once complete, the game is fully playable, and as long as the cartridge is in the Switch 2, there is no need for an internet connection to play it.

Can I sell or borrow a Game-Key Card game? 

Yes. A Game-Key Card game functions like any standard Switch 2 game; it simply doesn't contain the game itself. Instead, the card, as the name implies, serves as a key to unlock a downloaded version of the game, and it needs to be inserted into the console to play it. If lent to someone else or sold, the other person would need to download the game data to their Switch 2 and insert the card to play. 

What other titles make use of the Game-Key Card feature? 

Third-party games such as Street Fighter 6, Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster and Nobunaga's Ambition: Awakening for now. Every game that uses the feature will have a key icon on the cover indicating the amount of data that must be downloaded.

a sample package of a game's cover that has the game-key card key icon on it

A sample of what the Game-Key Card icon looks like on a Switch 2 game cover.

Nintendo

What's the point of the Game-Key Card feature? 

Nintendo has yet to be upfront about why it instituted the Game-Key Card feature for the Switch 2. Nintendo President Shuntaro Furukawa said in a call with investors this past July that it would help the company "strive to receive active support" from third-party developers, as reported by Nintendo Everything. 

It does seem, however, that the most likely reason is simply costs. Since the Switch 2 can handle higher-end graphics, it requires sufficient storage for the larger game files. The current maximum size for Switch 2 cartridges is 64GB, confirmed by Cyberpunk 2077 developer CD Projekt Red, which uses the entire cartridge for Switch 2 in its game. Some games are going to require more space, such as the upcoming Final Fantasy 7 Remake Intergrade, which is set to require 88GB of storage. For those games, a Game-Key Card will be the only way to be playable on the Switch 2 via a physical cartridge. 

Still, a game such as Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster only takes up just over 9GB of storage, yet it still uses a Game-Key Card. This means Nintendo could offer discounted cartridges to developers who utilize the Game-Key Card, as they require significantly less storage space on the actual cartridge. Although it has yet to be confirmed, this would help explain why Super Mario Kart World for the Switch 2 is the first game to have a regular price of $80, which would help offset some of the costs associated with releasing it on a physical cartridge. 

Patrocinados
Patrocinados
Upgrade to Pro
Choose the Plan That's Right for You
Patrocinados
Patrocinados
Publicaciones
Read More
Download the Telestraw App!
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
×