Article content

It’s worth noting that April 28 is two days before the personal tax filing deadline. Tax accountants — professionals who read and interpret federal fiscal policy — will be buried through that entire week. You could not design worse timing.

Article content

Canadians in general should appreciate the effect of moving the timing of the budget to the fall, accompanied by a spring update. The federal government’s fiscal year starts on April 1. Accordingly, early spring budgets have historically been presented to project the upcoming year.

Article content

Having an earlier budget release is fine by me, but the question is how much earlier? By definition, fall can be anywhere from late September to late December, or four to six months before the start of the government’s fiscal year. A lot can happen during that time.

Article content

There have been fall budgets during our country’s history. Jean Chrétien tabled his first budget in November 1978. John Crosbie presented the Dec. 11, 1979, budget that brought down Joe Clark’s government two days later. Allan MacEachen tabled the Oct. 28, 1980, budget. Fall budgets were briefly the pattern, but they stopped because they didn’t work.

Article content

Article content

Michael Wilson’s Department of Finance explained why in a 1985 paper that considered the exact same question Carney has answered without consultation. Wilson concluded mid-January to mid-February was optimal for a budget, naming the fatal flaw of fall budgets plainly: “a fall budget forecast is likely to be less reliable” because it is prepared too many months in advance of the fiscal year.

Article content

He then formally referred his paper to both House and Senate committees for scrutiny. That is how you handle a major change to the budgetary process. You don’t announce it on a Monday and quote the IMF on a Tuesday.

Article content

Also, consider what’s happened since Nov. 4: the United States-Iran conflict, the Strait of Hormuz blockade and the regime change in Venezuela. None of that could have been forecasted, so the November 2025 budget forecasts are likely out of date.

Article content

Are we really building the strongest economy in the G7? Royal Bank of Canada released a report last week that said Canada saw a net capital outflow of more than $1 trillion — the largest capital exodus in Canadian history — between 2015 and 2024. For every dollar in, two dollars left. Canada ranked last in the G7 for capital investment. That’s concerning given there’s no real plan to reverse course.

Article content

Article content

Which brings us back to Lt. Drebin.

Article content

Operating and capital split? Nothing to see here. Budget cycle adjusted without parliamentary study? Please disperse. A fiscal anchor with a 7.5 per cent probability of holding? Move along. A trillion dollars of capital gone and an IMF blessing with fireworks rolled out 11 days before the spring update? Nothing to see here. The government is waving its arms and telling Canadians not to look.

Article content

The difference between The Naked Gun and Carney’s fiscal strategy is that one of them is knowingly funny.

Article content

Kim Moody, FCPA, FCA, TEP, is the founder of Moodys Tax/Moodys Private Client, a former chair of the Canadian Tax Foundation, former chair of the Society of Estate Practitioners (Canada) and has held many other leadership positions in the Canadian tax community. He can be reached at kgcm@kimgcmoody.com and his LinkedIn profile is https://www.linkedin.com/in/kimgcmoody.

Article content

_____________________________________________________________

Article content

If you like this story, sign up for the FP Investor Newsletter.

Article content

_____________________________________________________________

Article content

Article content